Comments on: Learning at Law School – Of High Tables and Floors http://www.nlsquirks.in/learning-at-law-school-of-high-tables-and-floors/ NLSIU's magazine on Law School life and musings! Sun, 17 May 2020 20:01:08 +0000 hourly 1 https://wordpress.org/?v=5.1.5 By: Sahil Kher http://www.nlsquirks.in/learning-at-law-school-of-high-tables-and-floors/#comment-8053 Sun, 17 May 2020 20:01:08 +0000 http://www.nlsquirks.in/?p=9129#comment-8053 This is a great piece, thank you for writing it.

]]>
By: Deepak http://www.nlsquirks.in/learning-at-law-school-of-high-tables-and-floors/#comment-8045 Sat, 16 May 2020 05:11:51 +0000 http://www.nlsquirks.in/?p=9129#comment-8045 Well written and as someone who studied in the same place and would have likely been blind to this sort of experience, thank you for giving me more perspective.

]]>
By: Bharath Lakshminarayana http://www.nlsquirks.in/learning-at-law-school-of-high-tables-and-floors/#comment-8040 Fri, 15 May 2020 08:25:40 +0000 http://www.nlsquirks.in/?p=9129#comment-8040 Waste of my time. What was the purpose of the article, please ?

Language, both written and spoken, is an important skill for a lawyer – tool as Lord Denning mentioned (unless you think he also belongs to a patriarchal, brahmanical caste-based society that you ought not to read-up). If you disagree with this, god bless you in your career. If you are having a heavy accent in your English, which third party will hear you ? What confidence does a client get from your accent ? Which judge will want to hear your arguments patiently ? While I understand taunting is not a good reaction, isn’t it natural ? Are all human beings (forget NLS students, forget lawyers or shining beacons of our own backward community) models of humility ? Why do you whine ? If you are sincere, you will work to get a good accent and not say ‘Take me as I am’. Even pets don’t come to us if we are not nice to them – how do you expect humans to ?

I believe you’ve been growing up in a lot of this ‘rights without duties / responsibilities / liabilities’ culture; a lot of theorists who have no skin in the game appeared to have influenced you. I also think the AIR of 333 got your head wrongly in the clouds – academic distinction is a minuscule part of one’s life and one of the most misleading as well. Akbar was an illiterate but was a genius. Babasaheb was a superb exception. Grow up as a human being first in the tradition of this great country – don’t ape the ‘rights’ culture of the West. Discharge your duties / responsibilities / liabilities – then see the debate of the enlightened past masters on the idea of ‘fairness’.

]]>
By: Rohan Desai http://www.nlsquirks.in/learning-at-law-school-of-high-tables-and-floors/#comment-8036 Thu, 14 May 2020 16:28:51 +0000 http://www.nlsquirks.in/?p=9129#comment-8036 Greetings to the author. You very conveniently ignored the merit point in your above tryst with reality. Do you really think each person or majority of people belonging to the scheduled castes/tribes are genuinely unable to access the so called resources. Don’t you think that someone’s destitution has no link with his caste. How come you justify that you belong to a less priviliged household. I am in support of the reservation based on economic weaker sections. It may again sent you in a deja vu of your first year, but the bitter truth is there are more hardworking and dedicated ( deserving people who scored better than you) yet you are where they deserved to be. Maybe they have more academic pressure tolerance than you. Pleaae don’t pseudo- sympathise or try to justify the wretched reservation system that our country follows.

]]>
By: Sandeep Parekh http://www.nlsquirks.in/learning-at-law-school-of-high-tables-and-floors/#comment-8033 Thu, 14 May 2020 12:27:51 +0000 http://www.nlsquirks.in/?p=9129#comment-8033 More power to you – wonderfully articulated. I hope it makes people think a bit more about being judgmental and condescending.

]]>
By: Divesh Singh http://www.nlsquirks.in/learning-at-law-school-of-high-tables-and-floors/#comment-8029 Thu, 14 May 2020 08:22:47 +0000 http://www.nlsquirks.in/?p=9129#comment-8029 Caste Reservation was extended to 2030, Last Year.
You can keep dreaming, Modi himself boasts being OBC.
Dalits are here to stay.
We have just started and you think you can stop it, hahaha.

]]>
By: 'ഉന്നത'കലാലയങ്ങളിൽ മാറ്റി നിർത്തപ്പെട്ടവരുടെ ലോകം | OPEN PRESS | ഓപ്പണ്‍ പ്രസ്സ് | Malayalam News http://www.nlsquirks.in/learning-at-law-school-of-high-tables-and-floors/#comment-8022 Wed, 13 May 2020 13:05:12 +0000 http://www.nlsquirks.in/?p=9129#comment-8022 […] NLSUI അവസാന വർഷം വിദ്യാർത്ഥി അഭിഷേക് ആശാ കുമാർ nlsquirks ഇൽ എഴുതിയതിന്റെ സ്വതന്ത്ര മൊഴിമാറ്റം. ഒറിജിനൽ വായിക്കാൻ ഇവിടെ ക്ലിക്ക് ചെയ്യുക. […]

]]>
By: Girija Shankar http://www.nlsquirks.in/learning-at-law-school-of-high-tables-and-floors/#comment-8019 Wed, 13 May 2020 11:58:07 +0000 http://www.nlsquirks.in/?p=9129#comment-8019 Reservation has never been given just for the economic upliftment but it also includes representation at every level so that, marginalised people can be involved in the decision making process. Besides , I find people supporting women representation at parliament (33%) but criticising reservation for the SC/ST. Hypocrisy is the name of the game .Right ? Let’s show some empathy rather than trying to be abrasive.

]]>
By: Deeshna A http://www.nlsquirks.in/learning-at-law-school-of-high-tables-and-floors/#comment-8013 Tue, 12 May 2020 15:00:10 +0000 http://www.nlsquirks.in/?p=9129#comment-8013 Hi, I came across this article on Twitter. I’m glad to have spent time to read this powerful moving piece. I wouldn’t compare myself to you, neither do I share the privilege of my upper caste classmates. I also was once seated in a supposedly premiere institution for Social Sciences and found my lower caste peers struggling with English language as the privilege ones standing tall with historic pride built on caste and inequalities and they mocked them for poor language and manners. I do not intend to be a sympathiser but I always wanted to see my lower caste peers in the same ability as my upper caste and worked hard in the possible ways to help them academically and socially and emotionally. I hope more of you rise and show what you stand and have a platform to not just excel but also get the struggle out through writing into diverse voices of equality into the streets.

]]>
By: Bharathi http://www.nlsquirks.in/learning-at-law-school-of-high-tables-and-floors/#comment-8012 Tue, 12 May 2020 11:23:59 +0000 http://www.nlsquirks.in/?p=9129#comment-8012 Such an inspiring story. Gave me confidence congrats

]]>